Home

Former county appraiser. Current problem for the county.

I used to set property values. Now I make them suck less.

I’m David Carpenter. I spent six years inside the Guadalupe Appraisal District. Now I sit on your side of the table, and I read your file like someone who used to write them.

Protests across Texas. Based in New Braunfels. $100 a year plus 25% of what I save you.

David Carpenter, founder of PropertyTaxesSuck.io

Yes, the hair is real.
90%Of 2026 protests reduced
$107KAvg value cut, Guadalupe County, 2026
14.8%Avg cut off the notice value, Guadalupe 2026
#1Avg reduction of any agent, Guadalupe County, 2025

Why it matters who reads your file

Most tax firms read a spreadsheet.
I read the details.

The district values thousands of properties with one model. The model’s wrong a lot. Nobody checks.

I know where it’s wrong because I used to run it. I know which comps a district accepts, which ones it ignores, and which appraiser will actually pick up the phone.

That’s not a pitch. It’s just the job, done by someone who’s seen the other side of it.

The photo everyone scrolled past

A Fredericksburg house had its garage counted as living space. For years. Every firm that looked at it saw a number and moved on.

I zoomed in on a thumbnail photo in the district’s own evidence and saw a garage door.

$99,730

off the value. The district’s evidence packet is where the errors live.

Pick your door

One house or one hundred. Same guy.

I own my home

Sign up in about two minutes. I file the protest, build the evidence, and handle the hearing. You don’t show up. You don’t fill anything in. I re-file every year.

Start my protest

I own a portfolio

Rentals, commercial, land, a pile of LLCs. You get one person who knows every file, one report back to you, and nobody learning your properties on the morning of the hearing.

How portfolio work works

Investors, funds, operators

Built for owners with more than one tax bill.

National firms push your files through a queue and send whoever’s cheapest to the hearing. I’m a former appraiser who reads every file. That’s the whole difference, and it shows up in the final value.

Portfolio Protests

Every account, every district

Residential, commercial, and land across Texas districts, protested as one book and reported back as one book.

Business Personal Property

Renditions done right

Rendition filing and the new $125,000 BPP exemption, including the related-entity rules that trip people up.

Builders and Developers

Inventory valuation

Section 23.12 inventory filings so unsold product isn’t taxed like a finished sale.

The Weird Stuff

Things other firms won’t touch

Combining tracts into one account, fixing district records, and prior-year corrections where the law allows it.

Hearings

Someone who’s sat on both sides

ARB panels listen differently when the agent used to be the appraiser. I bring paper, not a screen share.

Confidential Accounts

Quiet when it needs to be

Accounts flagged confidential get handled that way, start to finish.

Send me your list of properties. I’ll get every one of them protested, then report back on the whole book.

Email David

The least boring guy in the most boring industry.I named the company PropertyTaxesSuck because they do. If Geico can make car insurance fun, somebody can do it for property taxes.
About David
  • Six years as a county appraiserGuadalupe County Appraisal District, 2016 to 2022. I mailed the notices you’re mad about.
  • MBA. Texas Business Hall of Fame.Yes, the property tax guy has a business degree. It helps when one client’s book runs past 100 properties.
  • The hairTall, blond, sometimes dyed red. The red matches the logo. I’d love to say that was planned.
  • The gold sequin tux jacketFor black tie events. It’s the only tux in Texas with opinions about appraisal schedules.
  • Based in New BraunfelsLocal guy. Statewide work.
How it works for homeowners

Four steps. You do one.

1

Enter your address

Sign up all your properties in a couple of minutes. I pull your current appraisal.

2

I build the case

Comps, equity, and a hard look at the district’s own data on your property.

3

I file and fight

Filed before the May 15 deadline. I handle the informal review and the ARB hearing.

4

You pay less

If the value doesn’t come down, there’s no savings to share. I re-file every year.

Homeowners
$100 / year + 25% of savings
  • Protest filed every year
  • Hearing representation
  • Online account to track it
  • Texas-based chat, email, and text support

Sign up

Portfolios
Let’s talk / priced to the book
  • Multi-property and multi-entity
  • Commercial, BPP, land, inventory
  • One report for the whole portfolio
  • Direct line to David

Email David

Don’t take my word for it.

★★★★★5.0 on GoogleRead them on Google →

★★★★★

“David was able to save us more money than I thought possible. We even got an unexpected escrow return from the lower taxes. If you want real results and real service, call Property Taxes Suck.io. Thank you, Mr. Carpenter.”

Scott GibbonsGoogle review

★★★★★

“David is an exceptional service provider. I’ve been using his services for two years now, and I’m thoroughly impressed with his work. He keeps me fully informed throughout the process, and I highly recommend him to anyone seeking assistance in contesting their property taxes.”

Rose ZamoraGoogle review

★★★★★

“I have tried to protest my taxes on my own without any success. David made a huge difference and saved us a SIGNIFICANT amount of money this year!! Thank you!”

Jessica ElizondoGoogle review

Questions people actually ask

FAQ

Do I have to show up to the hearing?

No. I handle it. You’ll get updates, and the final number when it’s done.

When’s the deadline?

May 15, or 30 days after your notice is delivered, whichever’s later. Sign up now and I’m watching for your notice the day it lands.

Where do you work?

Across Texas. I’m based in New Braunfels, and I protest wherever your property is. Same Tax Code, same process, same price.

Didn’t you work for the appraisal district?

For six years. Now I use everything I learned there for the other side.

What if you don’t save me anything?

Then you pay the $100 and none of the 25%.

Your property taxes suck.
Let’s fix that.

Two minutes to sign up. I take it from there.

Protest my property

PropertyTaxesSuck.ioProperty tax protests in every Texas county · New Braunfels, TexasHomestead helpFAQBlog© 2026 PropertyTaxesSuck.io